The Farmer’s Dog vs. Ollie vs. NomNom (2026 Price, Calorie & Ingredient Comparison)
We ordered starter boxes from The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie, NomNom, and Spot & Tango to compare real monthly cost per pound, protein digestibility, and trial discounts.
Why it wins: Picky eaters, sensitive stomachs, and dog parents wanting 100% human-grade gently cooked recipes
Is Your Dog Cutest in America? Win $10,000 Cash!
Enter in 60 seconds for 100% FREE. Every pup registered during our Early-Bird window gets +25 Free Head-Start Votes, a custom Magazine Cover Contender poster, and helps feed shelter dogs!
2026 Top Picks & Side-by-Side Comparison
The Farmer’s Dog (Best Fresh Food Overall)
Best For: Picky eaters, sensitive stomachs, and dog parents wanting 100% human-grade gently cooked recipes
- Board-certified veterinary nutritionist recipes cooked at low temperatures in USDA kitchens
- Pre-portioned daily packs customized to your dog’s exact age, weight, and activity level
- Requires refrigerator/freezer storage
Ollie Fresh + Gently Baked Mixed Plans
Best For: Dog parents who want to mix wet fresh food with crunchy gently baked bites to lower monthly cost
- Flexible Half-Fresh or Mixed plans cut monthly feeding costs by 30%–40%
- Includes free airtight storage container ("Puptainer") and portion scoop with first box
- Subscription auto-renews unless paused in dashboard
NomNom Microbiome & Gut-Health Fresh Food
Best For: Dogs with chronic ear infections, paw licking, or loose stools needing targeted gut support
- Formulated by in-house PhD veterinary nutritionists with visible whole diced ingredients
- Slightly fewer protein varieties than Ollie
Spot & Tango UnKibble (Fresh Dry Food)
Best For: Owners who want whole human-grade ingredients without taking up freezer space
- Scoop-and-serve convenience using 100% fresh-dried meats, fruits, and veggies
- Ships only within the contiguous U.S.
Real 2026 Price Breakdown: The Farmer’s Dog vs. Ollie vs. NomNom
Check Safe Human Foods, Daily Calories & Breed Vet Costs
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I claim the 50%–60% trial discount on both The Farmer’s Dog and Ollie to see which my dog prefers?
Yes! Many dog parents order the 50%-off starter box from The Farmer’s Dog and the 60%-off starter box from Ollie to run a two-week taste and digestion test before keeping their favorite subscription.
Enter your dog free — $10,000 Pupupp competition
Upload a photo, get +25 free head-start votes, and help feed shelter dogs.
Enter Your Dog FreeMore Guides for Dog Parents
What Human Foods Can Dogs Eat? The Ultimate 2026 Safe vs. Toxic Food Chart
150 Cutest Boy & Girl Puppy Names Trending in 2026 (Plus How to Enter Your New Pup Free)
Best Dog DNA Tests & GPS Smart Collars in 2026 (Embark, Fi Series 3 & Chewy Compared)
Curated Gift & Keepsake Partner Guides
Verified Sister BrandWhy do coated "diamond simulant" and moissanite tennis bracelets look cloudy or disco-ball rainbow after 6 months? Here is how real solid 14k gold lab-grown diamonds compare.
Why do master bench jewelers actually prefer solid 14k gold over softer 18k gold for tennis bracelets and pavé eternity bands? Here is the metallurgy breakdown.
Compare certified D–F VS+ lab-grown diamond carat savings (60%–75% off mined retail) and find your exact bracelet or ring size.